1 00:00:01,122 --> 00:00:02,950 In the criminal justice system, 2 00:00:02,950 --> 00:00:06,662 sexually-based offenses are considered especially heinous 3 00:00:06,662 --> 00:00:07,918 In New York City, 4 00:00:07,918 --> 00:00:11,417 the dedicated detectives who investigate these vicious felonies are members 5 00:00:11,417 --> 00:00:14,453 of an elite squad known as The Special Victims Unit. 6 00:00:14,453 --> 00:00:16,224 These are their stories. 7 00:00:24,386 --> 00:00:26,072 Going for the river. 8 00:00:38,415 --> 00:00:39,944 Hey, there he goes! 9 00:00:44,537 --> 00:00:45,724 Watch out! 10 00:01:03,704 --> 00:01:05,195 Heard you two ran a marathon. 11 00:01:05,195 --> 00:01:06,084 Yeah, sure. 12 00:01:06,084 --> 00:01:07,946 The perp won. We lost him. 13 00:01:07,946 --> 00:01:10,126 Dispatch has your crime scene down on John street. 14 00:01:10,126 --> 00:01:11,558 First I want you to check out these cars. 15 00:01:11,558 --> 00:01:12,741 Which cars? 16 00:01:12,741 --> 00:01:14,671 The Jag and the Chevy. 17 00:01:14,671 --> 00:01:18,052 Our boy was hiding between. He wasn't wearing gloves. 18 00:01:18,052 --> 00:01:19,899 I'll dust for prints. 19 00:01:19,899 --> 00:01:21,312 Was the suspect armed? 20 00:01:21,312 --> 00:01:23,206 Not sure, never got that close to him. 21 00:01:23,206 --> 00:01:24,328 Any word on the victim? 22 00:01:24,328 --> 00:01:26,784 She's at downtown hospital moving on her own steam. 23 00:01:26,784 --> 00:01:29,912 Rape kit's done. They're just checking her for internal injuries. 24 00:01:29,912 --> 00:01:31,665 What did he do to her? 25 00:01:32,124 --> 00:01:33,595 Nikki? 26 00:01:34,014 --> 00:01:36,828 These detectives are from the special victims unit. 27 00:01:36,828 --> 00:01:38,886 Hi, Nikki. Can we come in? 28 00:01:39,028 --> 00:01:42,917 I'm detective Stabler. This is my partner, detective Beck. 29 00:01:44,179 --> 00:01:45,971 Why me? 30 00:01:45,971 --> 00:01:48,593 Why did he do this to me? 31 00:01:50,755 --> 00:01:53,023 We're gonna take care of you, Nikki. 32 00:01:53,023 --> 00:01:56,192 The first thing we're gonna do is get you some clothes, okay? 33 00:02:01,075 --> 00:02:02,822 �ڸ����� - NSC �ڸ��� (http://club.nate.com/tsm) 34 00:02:03,212 --> 00:02:05,212 �����̼� ��ö��(kim1047@nate.com) 35 00:02:05,212 --> 00:02:07,112 ��ũ���� ������(seedyun@nate.com) 36 00:02:07,112 --> 00:02:09,122 �ѱ۹��� (http://club.nate.com/tsm) 37 00:02:09,419 --> 00:02:11,510 ũ���� ��δ� (������ �����̺��� ���� �) 38 00:02:13,394 --> 00:02:15,713 ������ī �ϱ����� (�ø���� ���� ���� �) 39 00:02:16,925 --> 00:02:18,796 ������ ���� (�� ��ġ ���� �) 40 00:02:20,620 --> 00:02:22,644 ���̾� �� (���̽� ��� �˻� �) 41 00:02:23,605 --> 00:02:25,580 ���̽�-Ƽ (������ "��" ƩƩ�ö� ���� �) 42 00:02:27,612 --> 00:02:29,739 B.D. �� (FBI ���źм��� ���� Ȳ �) 43 00:02:30,997 --> 00:02:33,177 Ÿ���� Ʃ�� (�Ḱ�� ���� �˽ð� �) 44 00:02:34,347 --> 00:02:36,449 �� �÷η� (�� ũ���̰� �氨 �) 45 00:02:37,739 --> 00:02:41,122 Law and Order SVU 8x03 Recall 46 00:02:41,522 --> 00:02:43,522 �������� (http://club.nate.com/tsm) 47 00:02:43,522 --> 00:02:45,522 �ѱ۱��� (http://club.nate.com/tsm) 48 00:02:45,522 --> 00:02:47,522 ORIGINAL AIR DATE ON NBC: 2006/10/03 49 00:02:50,150 --> 00:02:51,388 - How's Nikki? - Comfortable. 50 00:02:51,388 --> 00:02:54,831 Waiting for yours truly to find her a ginger ale in this dump. 51 00:02:54,831 --> 00:02:55,898 How bad? 52 00:02:55,898 --> 00:02:58,259 She told the doc M to P, P to V. 53 00:02:58,259 --> 00:02:59,529 M to P? 54 00:02:59,529 --> 00:03:02,533 Mouth to penis. P to V... 55 00:03:02,533 --> 00:03:04,521 Get it. 56 00:03:04,806 --> 00:03:06,349 You usually catch these perps? 57 00:03:06,349 --> 00:03:09,030 Well, most rapes, the women know their attacker, 58 00:03:09,030 --> 00:03:11,037 so those become he said/she said cases. 59 00:03:11,037 --> 00:03:12,984 Those are the toughest to prove what actually happened. 60 00:03:12,984 --> 00:03:14,558 What about serial rapists? 61 00:03:14,558 --> 00:03:16,345 We had 11 working Manhattan last year. 62 00:03:16,345 --> 00:03:18,201 We collared seven. Two by accident. 63 00:03:18,201 --> 00:03:21,809 They were just cold DNA hits on guys in the system already. 64 00:03:21,809 --> 00:03:23,572 You ready? 65 00:03:23,838 --> 00:03:25,092 Ready? 66 00:03:25,092 --> 00:03:28,235 To interview the victim while it's still fresh in her head. 67 00:03:28,537 --> 00:03:31,230 I've collared a few rapists who were wanted on other charges. 68 00:03:31,230 --> 00:03:32,466 Why don't I hit the computer 69 00:03:32,466 --> 00:03:36,606 and see if CRIMS has anyone with our guy's M.O. and an active warrant? 70 00:03:36,771 --> 00:03:38,553 Good idea. 71 00:03:40,383 --> 00:03:43,049 What happened next, Nikki? 72 00:03:43,981 --> 00:03:46,103 He... 73 00:03:47,701 --> 00:03:53,169 he made me get on my knees and... 74 00:03:54,015 --> 00:03:57,092 and go down on him. 75 00:03:57,092 --> 00:04:03,387 And then he told me to pull down my pants and... 76 00:04:03,597 --> 00:04:07,336 and slammed me up against the wall, 77 00:04:07,336 --> 00:04:13,042 and raped me from behind. 78 00:04:13,297 --> 00:04:16,635 Did he do anything when he was done? 79 00:04:16,886 --> 00:04:19,354 He, uh... 80 00:04:20,390 --> 00:04:28,204 he wiped me down with those wet naps that have alcohol in them. 81 00:04:28,204 --> 00:04:30,602 - Anything at the crime scene? - Nothing. 82 00:04:30,602 --> 00:04:35,104 CSU couldn't find hairs, fibers, or any of the trash from those wipes. 83 00:04:35,104 --> 00:04:37,084 How about what he looked like? 84 00:04:37,084 --> 00:04:41,034 I think he was older like... 85 00:04:41,034 --> 00:04:42,660 like in his 40s. 86 00:04:42,660 --> 00:04:45,124 Could you describe him to one of our artists? 87 00:04:45,124 --> 00:04:47,144 Yeah. I'll try. 88 00:04:47,431 --> 00:04:49,519 But it was dark. 89 00:04:50,092 --> 00:04:53,466 I, I saw something on his hand though. 90 00:04:53,466 --> 00:04:56,250 What was on his hand? 91 00:04:56,250 --> 00:04:58,601 A scar. 92 00:04:58,601 --> 00:05:01,375 It looked like, uh, like a capital L, 93 00:05:01,375 --> 00:05:05,705 but with the bottom line going the wrong way. 94 00:05:08,696 --> 00:05:10,350 First precinct just called. 95 00:05:10,350 --> 00:05:11,930 No sign of him. 96 00:05:11,930 --> 00:05:14,291 Probably hopped on a subway. 97 00:05:14,526 --> 00:05:16,688 You shut the door? 98 00:05:19,058 --> 00:05:21,651 - Everything okay? - Well, you tell me. 99 00:05:21,651 --> 00:05:23,817 How's she doing out there? 100 00:05:23,817 --> 00:05:26,799 Great. We were totally in synch chasing down the perp. 101 00:05:26,799 --> 00:05:28,725 Word on her is that she's a pro. 102 00:05:28,725 --> 00:05:30,688 Maybe too much of one. 103 00:05:30,688 --> 00:05:33,105 I'm hearing her CO in Warrants dumped her. 104 00:05:33,105 --> 00:05:34,264 For what? 105 00:05:34,264 --> 00:05:35,789 Being overzealous. 106 00:05:35,789 --> 00:05:39,021 Average collars per month for a Warrants detective is 8. 107 00:05:39,021 --> 00:05:41,357 She's bringing in 12, 13 perps. 108 00:05:41,357 --> 00:05:43,435 Right, and making everybody else look bad. 109 00:05:43,435 --> 00:05:45,004 That's not overzealous. That's talent. 110 00:05:45,004 --> 00:05:46,170 Going through the wrong door 111 00:05:46,170 --> 00:05:49,765 and roughing up some innocent civilian doesn't show talent. 112 00:05:49,765 --> 00:05:51,661 Now, it's only rumor, and I don't know the circumstances, 113 00:05:51,661 --> 00:05:54,010 but until I find out otherwise, 114 00:05:54,010 --> 00:05:56,022 you keep an eye on her. 115 00:05:56,372 --> 00:05:58,296 Excuse me, captain. Am I interrupting? 116 00:05:58,296 --> 00:05:59,917 Not at all. You got something? 117 00:05:59,917 --> 00:06:02,271 Oh, yeah. I spoke to O'Halloran. 118 00:06:02,271 --> 00:06:05,077 CSU hit pay dirt on the prints off the Jaguar. 119 00:06:05,077 --> 00:06:06,987 Barry Cole, 32. 120 00:06:06,987 --> 00:06:09,498 Did a nickel at Fishkill for a push-in robbery. 121 00:06:09,498 --> 00:06:11,030 Which turned into an assault. 122 00:06:11,030 --> 00:06:12,485 Last known address Brooklyn. 123 00:06:12,485 --> 00:06:14,119 Go get him. 124 00:06:15,253 --> 00:06:16,646 It's two blocks away. 125 00:06:16,646 --> 00:06:18,903 - The city pay for that thing? - No, I did. 126 00:06:18,903 --> 00:06:20,498 But it's worth every penny. 127 00:06:20,498 --> 00:06:25,103 It's my contacts, email, internet, maps, you name it. 128 00:06:25,103 --> 00:06:27,132 - You should get one. - No, thanks. 129 00:06:27,132 --> 00:06:30,760 My kids had to help me program the speed dial on my cell phone. 130 00:06:30,760 --> 00:06:32,807 No way. 131 00:06:33,351 --> 00:06:35,824 What's that accent? European or something? 132 00:06:35,824 --> 00:06:37,170 I was born in Denmark. 133 00:06:37,170 --> 00:06:39,908 I came here after I got married. 134 00:06:40,738 --> 00:06:42,225 Your husband from Denmark? 135 00:06:42,225 --> 00:06:44,891 No, from here. 136 00:06:45,703 --> 00:06:48,614 But he was stationed in Germany when he was in the military, 137 00:06:48,614 --> 00:06:52,193 and we met when I was studying there. 138 00:06:53,410 --> 00:06:55,964 What happened to your partner? 139 00:06:56,314 --> 00:07:00,447 Olivia got pulled for an undercover job. 140 00:07:00,883 --> 00:07:03,908 How long were you together? 141 00:07:05,169 --> 00:07:06,775 Seven years. 142 00:07:06,775 --> 00:07:08,798 How long were you in Warrants? 143 00:07:08,798 --> 00:07:10,880 Three and a half. 144 00:07:10,880 --> 00:07:12,943 Just had enough? 145 00:07:13,762 --> 00:07:15,771 It's up here. Turn left. 146 00:07:21,336 --> 00:07:23,417 Look under the door. 147 00:07:26,051 --> 00:07:27,529 Who the hell is it? 148 00:07:27,529 --> 00:07:29,377 Police! 149 00:07:29,632 --> 00:07:30,765 How many? 150 00:07:30,765 --> 00:07:33,924 Wait a minute. I gotta put something on. 151 00:07:34,193 --> 00:07:35,892 I need you to open that door now. 152 00:07:35,892 --> 00:07:37,480 Okay! 153 00:07:39,454 --> 00:07:41,265 What do you want at this hour? 154 00:07:41,265 --> 00:07:42,171 Barry Cole? 155 00:07:42,171 --> 00:07:43,876 He's not here. I haven't seen him. 156 00:07:43,876 --> 00:07:45,408 Mind if we come on in, take a look? 157 00:07:45,408 --> 00:07:47,617 Just make it quick 'cause I gotta work in the morning. 158 00:07:47,617 --> 00:07:50,061 I gotta get some sleep. 159 00:07:50,751 --> 00:07:53,616 Did Barry do something wrong? 160 00:07:53,616 --> 00:07:54,876 Who sleeps here? 161 00:07:54,876 --> 00:07:56,869 I fell asleep watching TV. 162 00:07:56,869 --> 00:07:58,824 Stabler! 163 00:08:00,475 --> 00:08:02,806 It's still warm. Someone was just sleeping here. 164 00:08:02,806 --> 00:08:04,741 Ophelia, you're lying. 165 00:08:04,741 --> 00:08:06,462 Where is he? 166 00:08:08,146 --> 00:08:09,461 He's running! Take the front. 167 00:08:09,461 --> 00:08:10,617 Got it! 168 00:08:18,996 --> 00:08:20,406 Come on! 169 00:08:30,597 --> 00:08:32,472 Come on, get up. 170 00:08:32,472 --> 00:08:34,804 Barry Cole, you're under arrest for rape. 171 00:08:34,804 --> 00:08:37,106 Rape? I didn't rape anybody. 172 00:08:37,664 --> 00:08:39,938 Impact baton, huh? 173 00:08:40,952 --> 00:08:43,605 You should lose the sports jacket and shoes. 174 00:08:43,605 --> 00:08:45,619 They slow you down. 175 00:08:47,919 --> 00:08:51,064 If you wanna see me, you two people, you sure take me to the hospital. 176 00:08:51,064 --> 00:08:52,082 Shut up! 177 00:08:52,082 --> 00:08:53,815 - Hey, great work on those prints. - Thanks. 178 00:08:53,815 --> 00:08:56,576 - Hey, uh, you got a second? - Yeah. Your collar. 179 00:08:56,576 --> 00:08:58,677 I'll get them both. Come on, sweetheart. 180 00:08:58,677 --> 00:09:02,158 Did she, uh, tell you anything about our conversation last night? 181 00:09:02,158 --> 00:09:04,519 Just that you got a match on Barry Cole. Why? 182 00:09:04,519 --> 00:09:07,561 Because I told her I wasn't done processing all the prints when she called. 183 00:09:07,561 --> 00:09:08,865 You're saying it's not Barry? 184 00:09:08,865 --> 00:09:10,840 The Jaguar we found his prints on was a rental. 185 00:09:10,840 --> 00:09:13,739 So I called the rental agency. Barry works there processing cars. 186 00:09:13,739 --> 00:09:15,899 Okay, so he borrowed one to do the rape. / I don't think so. 187 00:09:15,899 --> 00:09:20,204 The only place I found his prints were on the passenger side window. 188 00:09:22,840 --> 00:09:24,987 Our guy was hiding next to the driver's side. 189 00:09:24,987 --> 00:09:27,981 Also, your guy was probably crouched like this. 190 00:09:27,981 --> 00:09:30,169 Touching the car to keep his balance like this. 191 00:09:30,169 --> 00:09:31,724 Did you find that pattern on the Jag? 192 00:09:31,724 --> 00:09:34,154 Ten perfect fingertips. 193 00:09:35,492 --> 00:09:37,267 - In the system? - He's not in AFIS. 194 00:09:37,267 --> 00:09:38,741 He doesn't have a criminal record. 195 00:09:38,741 --> 00:09:40,194 But he's in the state system. 196 00:09:40,194 --> 00:09:43,754 Name's Martin Trenway. Printed back in '77 197 00:09:43,754 --> 00:09:47,550 when he became assistant district attorney here in Manhattan. 198 00:09:47,998 --> 00:09:49,389 Did you tell her that? 199 00:09:49,389 --> 00:09:50,734 Sure, I called her back, 200 00:09:50,734 --> 00:09:52,867 but, you know, Barry Cole's got a record. 201 00:09:52,867 --> 00:09:55,048 So she thought he looked good for it. 202 00:09:55,048 --> 00:09:56,741 Hey, whoa, I don't want to cause any problems. 203 00:09:56,741 --> 00:09:58,487 You just saved our asses. 204 00:09:58,833 --> 00:10:00,517 Detective Beck. 205 00:10:02,988 --> 00:10:04,451 Something wrong? 206 00:10:04,451 --> 00:10:05,929 Cut him loose. 207 00:10:06,070 --> 00:10:08,945 - Cut him loose why? - You know damn well why. 208 00:10:12,507 --> 00:10:14,929 Barry had a record. I thought he was the best lead. 209 00:10:14,929 --> 00:10:16,287 But he wasn't the only lead. 210 00:10:16,287 --> 00:10:17,926 Now if you'd only listen to O'Halloran, 211 00:10:17,926 --> 00:10:19,603 we wouldn't have spent the night chasing our tails 212 00:10:19,603 --> 00:10:21,801 instead of looking for this guy. 213 00:10:22,479 --> 00:10:24,933 Cut him loose before the captain finds out. 214 00:10:24,933 --> 00:10:27,058 Who's the piano player? 215 00:10:27,653 --> 00:10:30,211 A lawyer. Used to be an ADA. 216 00:10:32,626 --> 00:10:35,201 Law Offices of Martin Trenway 53 Water Street Tuesday, September 19 217 00:10:35,201 --> 00:10:37,173 How can I help you, detectives? 218 00:10:37,173 --> 00:10:39,302 We're here about the Jaguar you rented. 219 00:10:39,302 --> 00:10:42,417 I don't remember getting any parking tickets. 220 00:10:42,417 --> 00:10:45,382 A car by the same description was used in a robbery in Brooklyn yesterday. 221 00:10:45,382 --> 00:10:48,863 One of our officers spotted yours in a parking lot under the FDR drive. 222 00:10:48,863 --> 00:10:49,875 Called it in. 223 00:10:49,875 --> 00:10:51,667 You don't think I committed the crime, do you? 224 00:10:51,667 --> 00:10:54,491 Well, sir, you know how it is. We get the call... 225 00:10:54,491 --> 00:10:55,872 You have to check it out. 226 00:10:55,872 --> 00:10:57,401 Yeah, of course. 227 00:10:57,401 --> 00:10:59,164 Well, I, uh, 228 00:10:59,164 --> 00:11:02,845 I rented the car yesterday afternoon to go to Jersey for a deposition. 229 00:11:02,845 --> 00:11:04,795 You came back to the office afterward? 230 00:11:04,795 --> 00:11:07,691 Around 6 in the evening. 231 00:11:07,691 --> 00:11:10,985 Oh, I have a receipt from the toll at the Holland tunnel if you want to see it. 232 00:11:10,985 --> 00:11:12,148 No, that won't be necessary. 233 00:11:12,148 --> 00:11:13,771 I think we've taken up enough of your time. 234 00:11:13,771 --> 00:11:15,146 Oh, not at all. 235 00:11:15,146 --> 00:11:17,198 Glad to oblige. 236 00:11:17,198 --> 00:11:18,359 Carpal tunnel? 237 00:11:18,359 --> 00:11:22,703 Uh, no, just busted my wrist playing basketball. 238 00:11:22,703 --> 00:11:26,456 Teach me to set a pick against my 17-year-old son, huh? 239 00:11:29,455 --> 00:11:32,673 Typical trial lawyer. Has an answer for everything. 240 00:11:32,673 --> 00:11:36,477 I just want to see if he's got a backwards L-shaped scar underneath that brace of his. 241 00:11:36,477 --> 00:11:38,272 I don't need to. 242 00:11:38,557 --> 00:11:42,042 The composite Nikki West gave us looks a lot like him. 243 00:11:43,150 --> 00:11:44,757 Yeah, it looks a lot like Trenway. 244 00:11:44,757 --> 00:11:47,518 And probably 10,000 other white guys who live in the city. 245 00:11:47,518 --> 00:11:50,340 10,000 other white guys didn't leave their prints on that Jag. 246 00:11:50,340 --> 00:11:54,006 Yes, but Martin Trenway is one of the biggest personal injury attorneys in town. 247 00:11:54,006 --> 00:11:55,645 So if we're gonna accuse him, 248 00:11:55,645 --> 00:11:57,514 we gotta make sure we have our ducks in a row. 249 00:11:57,514 --> 00:12:00,152 What do we know about Trenway personally? 250 00:12:00,152 --> 00:12:04,298 54, grew up in Queens, Douglaston, Cardoso high school, 251 00:12:04,298 --> 00:12:06,423 college at Cornell, Duke law school. 252 00:12:06,423 --> 00:12:08,094 Married to the same woman for 30 years. 253 00:12:08,094 --> 00:12:10,029 Two teenage sons. Lives in Stanford, Connecticut. 254 00:12:10,029 --> 00:12:12,876 Keeps a pied--terre one block from Gracie mansion. 255 00:12:12,876 --> 00:12:15,284 And he's never been in trouble with the law. 256 00:12:15,284 --> 00:12:16,478 He's a lawyer. 257 00:12:16,478 --> 00:12:19,127 He knows how to hide evidence like our rapist. 258 00:12:19,127 --> 00:12:20,814 He's got his M.O. down cold. 259 00:12:20,814 --> 00:12:24,485 Middle-aged men don't suddenly become rapists out of the blue. 260 00:12:24,485 --> 00:12:26,511 Well, there are rare cases. 261 00:12:26,511 --> 00:12:30,262 High functioning men like Trenway sometimes have a history of psychosexual problems 262 00:12:30,262 --> 00:12:34,156 like addictions to pornography and violence that they've managed to keep under wraps. 263 00:12:34,156 --> 00:12:36,087 Let's put Trenway in a lineup. 264 00:12:36,087 --> 00:12:38,662 That's risky. I think we lucked out with the sketch. 265 00:12:38,662 --> 00:12:40,566 Nikki said that she didn't get a good look at him. 266 00:12:40,566 --> 00:12:42,804 But she did get a good look at his hand. 267 00:12:46,120 --> 00:12:47,397 Are you ready? 268 00:12:47,397 --> 00:12:48,946 I guess so. 269 00:12:53,327 --> 00:12:56,484 Gentlemen, make a fist. Keep your hand still. 270 00:13:25,236 --> 00:13:26,481 Thank you, gentlemen. 271 00:13:26,481 --> 00:13:29,709 You're arresting me because of a scar on my hand? 272 00:13:29,709 --> 00:13:33,442 Do you know how many people have one just like mine? 273 00:13:33,442 --> 00:13:35,279 Where's it from? 274 00:13:35,467 --> 00:13:38,773 Tendon transfer surgery from when I broke my wrist. 275 00:13:38,773 --> 00:13:39,475 You know what? 276 00:13:39,475 --> 00:13:41,729 I want to remind you again that you have the right to have an attorney present. 277 00:13:41,729 --> 00:13:43,826 I am attorney. I know my rights. 278 00:13:43,826 --> 00:13:45,600 I didn't do anything! 279 00:13:45,600 --> 00:13:48,291 Where were you last night around 11? 280 00:13:48,490 --> 00:13:49,827 My office, working late. 281 00:13:49,827 --> 00:13:51,475 Okay, think about this. 282 00:13:51,475 --> 00:13:52,666 What time did you leave? 283 00:13:52,666 --> 00:13:54,364 Around midnight. 284 00:13:54,364 --> 00:13:56,534 You can check the security logs of the building. 285 00:13:56,534 --> 00:13:57,574 We did. 286 00:13:57,574 --> 00:13:59,961 We also checked with the security guard on duty. 287 00:13:59,961 --> 00:14:02,291 He said you left at 9:45 288 00:14:02,291 --> 00:14:04,319 and told him not to bother putting it in the book. 289 00:14:04,319 --> 00:14:05,926 I stepped out to grab a bite. 290 00:14:05,926 --> 00:14:07,804 He said you were gone till around 11. 291 00:14:07,804 --> 00:14:13,183 Funny that the rape and the chase happened all around the same time. 292 00:14:13,183 --> 00:14:16,643 How many men are out on a street in that area at that hour, hmm? 293 00:14:16,643 --> 00:14:19,437 It's doesn't matter. We've got you. 294 00:14:19,437 --> 00:14:21,923 Show him the photos. 295 00:14:23,472 --> 00:14:27,541 Only one man hid behind this car and left his fingerprints. 296 00:14:28,696 --> 00:14:29,869 That'd be you. 297 00:14:29,869 --> 00:14:31,350 Come on! 298 00:14:32,600 --> 00:14:35,021 I dropped my briefcase when I got back from Jersey. 299 00:14:35,021 --> 00:14:38,843 It popped open. Some papers flew out. I... 300 00:14:38,843 --> 00:14:42,028 I guess I must've touched the car when I bent down to get them. 301 00:14:42,216 --> 00:14:44,384 Not like this you didn't. 302 00:14:46,950 --> 00:14:49,290 You're going to arraignment. 303 00:14:53,750 --> 00:14:55,974 Trenway's got a lot of friends in there and no priors. 304 00:14:55,974 --> 00:14:57,545 There's no way he was getting remanded. 305 00:14:57,545 --> 00:15:00,250 Right, but $25,000 bail? That's a joke. 306 00:15:00,250 --> 00:15:03,533 Maybe he'll do another rape between now and the trial. 307 00:15:04,549 --> 00:15:05,654 Where you going? 308 00:15:05,654 --> 00:15:07,017 Hey, guys. 309 00:15:07,017 --> 00:15:08,167 You want a story? 310 00:15:08,167 --> 00:15:09,878 I got a story for you. 311 00:15:09,878 --> 00:15:13,026 Martin Trenway, the big PI lawyer, right over there, 312 00:15:13,026 --> 00:15:15,426 just got charged with rape. 313 00:15:15,555 --> 00:15:17,430 - Still rolling? - Set. 314 00:15:18,765 --> 00:15:20,692 - Mr. Trenway. - Mr. Trenway, can we have a second? 315 00:15:20,692 --> 00:15:21,751 Is it true you've been charged with rape? 316 00:15:21,751 --> 00:15:25,638 Yes, yes, yes, but it is clearly a case of mistaken identity. 317 00:15:25,638 --> 00:15:27,141 Do you have anything else to say? 318 00:15:27,141 --> 00:15:29,279 When do the police say it happened? 319 00:15:29,637 --> 00:15:32,160 Hand lineup was a good idea. 320 00:15:32,814 --> 00:15:34,383 Trenway's right, though. 321 00:15:34,383 --> 00:15:37,491 A lot of people probably have that same scar. 322 00:15:37,646 --> 00:15:39,946 I'm detective Tutuola. You don't want to talk to me. 323 00:15:39,946 --> 00:15:42,820 This is the detective that got his mug on the front page. 324 00:15:42,820 --> 00:15:44,741 Detective Beck, this is Heather Stark. 325 00:15:44,741 --> 00:15:46,738 - She'd like to say thank you. - I knew when I saw the pictures... 326 00:15:46,738 --> 00:15:49,806 You don't have to say anything. I was just doing my job. 327 00:15:49,806 --> 00:15:50,958 But... 328 00:15:50,958 --> 00:15:52,581 but I remember him. 329 00:15:52,581 --> 00:15:54,420 I'm detective Stabler. 330 00:15:54,682 --> 00:15:55,957 Hi. 331 00:15:57,936 --> 00:16:00,168 You recognize that man? 332 00:16:00,168 --> 00:16:01,548 Five years ago, 333 00:16:01,548 --> 00:16:05,606 I was going into a subway station on 104th and Broadway 334 00:16:05,606 --> 00:16:10,758 when a man knocked me into a parked car. 335 00:16:11,733 --> 00:16:16,146 I fell and something hit me in the head like he kicked me. 336 00:16:16,146 --> 00:16:18,018 What happened next? 337 00:16:18,018 --> 00:16:22,190 He opened the car and pushed me into the back seat. 338 00:16:22,190 --> 00:16:23,700 And then he hit me again. 339 00:16:23,700 --> 00:16:26,356 Do you remember what kind of car it was? 340 00:16:26,651 --> 00:16:29,059 - No. - Okay. 341 00:16:29,874 --> 00:16:31,842 He knocked me out, 342 00:16:31,842 --> 00:16:35,785 because when I woke up, 343 00:16:36,145 --> 00:16:38,951 we were in some abandoned lot. 344 00:16:38,951 --> 00:16:41,193 He had a knife. 345 00:16:41,763 --> 00:16:43,915 He... 346 00:16:44,115 --> 00:16:47,496 made me perform oral sex. 347 00:16:47,496 --> 00:16:50,547 And he raped me. 348 00:16:51,512 --> 00:16:54,634 What happened afterwards? 349 00:16:54,798 --> 00:16:58,069 He made me get out of the car. 350 00:16:59,390 --> 00:17:00,751 And he took off. 351 00:17:00,751 --> 00:17:04,139 And somehow I found my way to a gas station. 352 00:17:04,139 --> 00:17:07,643 Turned out he drove me to Long Island city. 353 00:17:07,643 --> 00:17:12,732 Now, why are you so sure Martin Trenway is the man who raped you? 354 00:17:15,317 --> 00:17:18,056 We were in the car. 355 00:17:19,902 --> 00:17:25,159 He tried to rape me from behind. 356 00:17:25,755 --> 00:17:29,615 But he was too tall, so he got on top of me. 357 00:17:29,830 --> 00:17:36,485 He told me to close my eyes, but I didn't. So... 358 00:17:39,607 --> 00:17:43,823 When I saw this picture, I started to shake. 359 00:17:45,734 --> 00:17:48,567 I know it's him. 360 00:17:51,466 --> 00:17:54,366 I'll never forget his face. 361 00:17:57,989 --> 00:18:00,153 Is there somebody I can call for you? 362 00:18:00,153 --> 00:18:03,198 Yeah, my friend Melissa would be a good person. 363 00:18:03,919 --> 00:18:05,917 Oh, my god. 364 00:18:06,340 --> 00:18:08,857 - Is that me? - John, this is Heather. 365 00:18:08,857 --> 00:18:10,987 She needs someplace private to make a phone call. 366 00:18:10,987 --> 00:18:12,501 My pleasure. 367 00:18:15,260 --> 00:18:16,496 What are you doing? 368 00:18:16,496 --> 00:18:20,471 That woman just relived the worst experience of her life. 369 00:18:20,642 --> 00:18:24,057 She doesn't need to see the way she looked that night. 370 00:18:24,302 --> 00:18:26,676 Her case file's right there. 371 00:18:26,861 --> 00:18:29,251 How'd you get it so fast? 372 00:18:29,437 --> 00:18:31,609 It was a Queens SVU case. 373 00:18:31,609 --> 00:18:34,505 They're swamped, so they let us have it. 374 00:18:34,505 --> 00:18:36,470 We watched you interview Heather. 375 00:18:36,470 --> 00:18:38,703 The rapist's M.O. is very close to Nikki West's. 376 00:18:38,703 --> 00:18:40,090 Check out the composites. 377 00:18:40,090 --> 00:18:41,935 Either of them could be Trenway. 378 00:18:41,935 --> 00:18:43,090 Heather's interview five years ago 379 00:18:43,090 --> 00:18:46,351 reads word for word with what she just told me. 380 00:18:46,351 --> 00:18:47,333 She's consistent. 381 00:18:47,333 --> 00:18:50,266 Well, the defense will still argue her ID of Trenway was improper. 382 00:18:50,266 --> 00:18:53,233 Oh, because she picked him out of the newspaper instead of a photo lineup. 383 00:18:53,233 --> 00:18:55,524 We may not need an ID. 384 00:18:55,524 --> 00:18:59,227 Heather's clothes and rape kit were inventoried with fluids present. 385 00:18:59,227 --> 00:19:02,220 DNA wouldn't have been processed back then unless they had a suspect. 386 00:19:02,220 --> 00:19:04,936 All the case evidence is at the property clerk in Queens. 387 00:19:04,936 --> 00:19:07,507 Statute of limitations is up in four days on this one. 388 00:19:07,507 --> 00:19:09,587 Get a warrant on Trenway's DNA. 389 00:19:09,587 --> 00:19:11,141 Find that evidence. 390 00:19:11,532 --> 00:19:14,324 NYPD Property Clerk Warehouse Queens, New York Thursday, September 21 391 00:19:14,324 --> 00:19:17,171 The log says that file number should be right here. 392 00:19:17,171 --> 00:19:19,262 Well, it's not here, so where do we look next? 393 00:19:19,262 --> 00:19:20,194 It could be anywhere. 394 00:19:20,194 --> 00:19:22,985 Place leaks so bad, we had to move stuff around. 395 00:19:22,985 --> 00:19:24,443 You mean you lost it? 396 00:19:24,443 --> 00:19:25,621 It's not lost. 397 00:19:25,621 --> 00:19:27,461 Sometimes it just takes a while to find it. 398 00:19:27,461 --> 00:19:28,446 So find it. 399 00:19:28,446 --> 00:19:30,366 I got two dozen cases ahead of you. 400 00:19:30,366 --> 00:19:32,194 - Could take a couple of weeks. - We don't have a couple of weeks. 401 00:19:32,194 --> 00:19:35,331 This one doesn't get found, we got a rapist who goes out on the street. 402 00:19:35,331 --> 00:19:37,261 You're on the list. 403 00:19:37,519 --> 00:19:41,009 No wonder they took your gun and stuck you in this hellhole. 404 00:19:41,203 --> 00:19:43,418 Screw you, lady. 405 00:19:43,609 --> 00:19:46,331 Now, you can find it yourself. 406 00:19:46,795 --> 00:19:48,652 Someone should've fired that idiot. 407 00:19:48,652 --> 00:19:51,908 So you got any friends who can undo the mess you just made in there? 408 00:19:52,665 --> 00:19:53,608 The mess I just made? 409 00:19:53,608 --> 00:19:56,983 Look, the guy may be a loser, but bullying him doesn't help us. 410 00:19:56,983 --> 00:19:57,859 So what are you saying? 411 00:19:57,859 --> 00:19:59,486 I'm saying you're running around half-cocked 412 00:19:59,486 --> 00:20:01,456 like you're still yanking bail jumpers off the street. 413 00:20:01,456 --> 00:20:03,133 It's about getting inside people's heads. 414 00:20:03,133 --> 00:20:05,135 Your problem is every perp smells the same to you. 415 00:20:05,135 --> 00:20:06,484 Yeah, they do. 416 00:20:06,484 --> 00:20:07,864 Well, they're not. 417 00:20:07,864 --> 00:20:09,247 They're not the same. 418 00:20:09,247 --> 00:20:11,452 You got Trenway. He's a lawyer. 419 00:20:11,452 --> 00:20:15,544 You get him in the box, you work him. You don't get in his face. 420 00:20:15,710 --> 00:20:18,019 And you don't turn your back on the victims. 421 00:20:18,019 --> 00:20:20,482 Like you did with Heather Stark. 422 00:20:22,817 --> 00:20:25,905 Trial Part 46 Monday, September 25 423 00:20:25,905 --> 00:20:27,973 Heather, can you please describe the injuries 424 00:20:27,973 --> 00:20:32,173 your attacker inflicted upon you in addition to the rape? 425 00:20:32,173 --> 00:20:34,845 He fractured my skull. 426 00:20:34,845 --> 00:20:38,508 Broke my nose and my right eye socket. 427 00:20:38,780 --> 00:20:40,472 My whole face was a mess. 428 00:20:40,472 --> 00:20:43,136 I needed plastic surgery. 429 00:20:43,136 --> 00:20:45,482 Do you know who did this to you? 430 00:20:45,482 --> 00:20:47,975 Yes. Martin Trenway. 431 00:20:48,429 --> 00:20:50,500 He's sitting right over there. 432 00:20:50,500 --> 00:20:51,974 Thank you. 433 00:20:52,240 --> 00:20:54,167 Nothing further. 434 00:21:01,172 --> 00:21:06,167 Ms. Stark, you testified that you were sure that Mr. Trenway raped you because... 435 00:21:06,167 --> 00:21:08,543 you recognized him from the newspapers. 436 00:21:08,543 --> 00:21:09,963 That's correct. 437 00:21:09,963 --> 00:21:13,908 The article printed after he had been arrested for another rape. 438 00:21:13,908 --> 00:21:15,679 Yes. 439 00:21:16,540 --> 00:21:18,814 How often do you read the paper? 440 00:21:18,814 --> 00:21:20,152 Every day. 441 00:21:20,152 --> 00:21:22,335 Any one in particular? 442 00:21:22,335 --> 00:21:23,998 The Ledger. 443 00:21:23,998 --> 00:21:27,855 You're aware that Mr. Trenway is a very well-known attorney in town. 444 00:21:27,855 --> 00:21:29,176 Yes, I am. 445 00:21:29,176 --> 00:21:32,376 So it wouldn't surprise you to hear that he'd been in the newspaper 446 00:21:32,376 --> 00:21:34,574 before he was accused of rape. 447 00:21:34,574 --> 00:21:36,337 No, it wouldn't. 448 00:21:36,337 --> 00:21:40,486 Do you know how many times Mr. Trenway's picture was in the Ledger 449 00:21:40,486 --> 00:21:43,307 in the five years since you were attacked? 450 00:21:43,307 --> 00:21:44,750 No, sir, I don't. 451 00:21:44,750 --> 00:21:46,814 22. 452 00:21:46,814 --> 00:21:49,374 22 times. 453 00:21:49,568 --> 00:21:51,069 So since you read the Ledger every day, 454 00:21:51,069 --> 00:21:53,089 you had to have seen my client's face before. 455 00:21:53,089 --> 00:21:55,148 Objection. Calls for speculation. 456 00:21:55,148 --> 00:21:57,270 I'll withdraw the question. 457 00:21:58,115 --> 00:21:59,805 Ms. Stark... 458 00:22:00,392 --> 00:22:03,270 isn't it possible you recognized my client 459 00:22:03,270 --> 00:22:05,812 because you'd seen him in the paper previously, 460 00:22:05,812 --> 00:22:08,149 not because he attacked you? 461 00:22:08,149 --> 00:22:13,220 I was looking at him the entire time he was raping me. 462 00:22:13,220 --> 00:22:15,822 I know it's him. 463 00:22:15,822 --> 00:22:18,446 Then why didn't you call the police one of the other 22 times 464 00:22:18,446 --> 00:22:21,305 you saw his face in the paper? 465 00:22:25,435 --> 00:22:27,633 I, I... 466 00:22:29,958 --> 00:22:31,836 I don't know. 467 00:22:33,330 --> 00:22:35,719 No further questions. 468 00:22:38,285 --> 00:22:41,857 Eyewitness testimony is the least reliable of all evidence. 469 00:22:41,857 --> 00:22:43,748 As an expert in the field, Dr. Polk, 470 00:22:43,748 --> 00:22:46,145 I'm sure that you can cite studies to back that up. 471 00:22:46,145 --> 00:22:47,611 Dozens of them. 472 00:22:47,611 --> 00:22:50,495 But the best proof comes from the real world. 473 00:22:50,495 --> 00:22:53,757 Of the first group of murderers and rapists 474 00:22:53,757 --> 00:22:56,923 whose convictions were overturned by DNA evidence, 475 00:22:56,923 --> 00:23:01,551 more than 80% were found guilty based on mistaken eyewitness testimony. 476 00:23:01,551 --> 00:23:04,180 Now, wait a minute. How is that possible, doctor? 477 00:23:04,180 --> 00:23:07,643 Most jurors believe that human memory works like a videotape. 478 00:23:07,643 --> 00:23:12,055 That our minds play back an event exactly as it was recorded. 479 00:23:12,055 --> 00:23:16,120 So when Ms. Stark says five years after she was raped 480 00:23:16,120 --> 00:23:20,248 that she is sure beyond any doubt that Mr. Trenway attacked her, 481 00:23:20,248 --> 00:23:21,474 is she lying? 482 00:23:21,474 --> 00:23:22,991 Absolutely not. 483 00:23:22,991 --> 00:23:27,502 She's telling the truth as she believes she remembers it. 484 00:23:27,502 --> 00:23:32,452 But her memory of that horrible event can always be changed by suggestion, 485 00:23:32,452 --> 00:23:34,630 whether intentional or not. 486 00:23:34,630 --> 00:23:37,008 Like a suggestion in a newspaper article, 487 00:23:37,008 --> 00:23:40,348 naming my client as a defendant in another rape case. 488 00:23:40,348 --> 00:23:41,975 Yes. 489 00:23:42,221 --> 00:23:44,225 Nothing further. 490 00:23:45,245 --> 00:23:47,417 People's seven, your honor. 491 00:23:47,731 --> 00:23:51,501 This is a composite based on a description Heather Stark gave detectives 492 00:23:51,501 --> 00:23:54,196 the night she was attacked five years ago. 493 00:23:54,196 --> 00:23:55,457 Help. 494 00:23:55,457 --> 00:23:58,802 Do you think it looks like Martin Trenway? 495 00:24:00,523 --> 00:24:01,944 Well, yes, it could be him, 496 00:24:01,944 --> 00:24:04,784 but the fact that he's sitting a few feet away is very suggestive, though. 497 00:24:04,784 --> 00:24:07,382 Yes, but we've heard testimony that for seven hours 498 00:24:07,382 --> 00:24:09,855 after Heather Stark was raped and beaten, 499 00:24:09,855 --> 00:24:12,761 she was first hospitalized, poked, prodded, photographed, 500 00:24:12,761 --> 00:24:15,534 sutured, cleaned up, and interviewed by the police. 501 00:24:15,534 --> 00:24:17,470 And yet after all that, 502 00:24:17,470 --> 00:24:21,021 after all the possible suggestion that she might have been influenced by, 503 00:24:21,021 --> 00:24:23,379 she still gave a description of her attacker 504 00:24:23,379 --> 00:24:27,144 that even you agree resembles the defendant. 505 00:24:30,106 --> 00:24:35,250 Dr. Polk, taking into account the trauma that she experienced, 506 00:24:35,250 --> 00:24:38,389 and given her accuracy then and her confidence now, 507 00:24:38,389 --> 00:24:45,676 isn't is possible Ms. Stark correctly identified Mr. Trenway as her attacker? 508 00:24:47,712 --> 00:24:49,869 Yes. 509 00:24:53,206 --> 00:24:55,331 Thank you, doctor. 510 00:24:57,233 --> 00:24:59,893 We'll pick up again after lunch. 511 00:25:32,186 --> 00:25:34,595 Tell me that you guys are here because you found it. 512 00:25:34,595 --> 00:25:36,501 It's already at the M.E.'s being processed. 513 00:25:36,501 --> 00:25:38,019 I gotta get the results in on rebuttal. 514 00:25:38,019 --> 00:25:40,302 Not so fast. There might be a problem. 515 00:25:41,733 --> 00:25:44,303 The rape kit and clothing at one time had been wet. 516 00:25:44,303 --> 00:25:47,174 That caused mold to grow on the biological material. 517 00:25:47,174 --> 00:25:48,386 So it's no good? 518 00:25:48,386 --> 00:25:49,719 We lucked out. 519 00:25:49,719 --> 00:25:52,645 Got a couple of DNA markers suitable for comparison. 520 00:25:52,645 --> 00:25:54,441 Okay, and? 521 00:25:54,905 --> 00:25:57,729 - I have definitive proof. - We got him. 522 00:25:57,729 --> 00:25:59,549 I wish. 523 00:25:59,681 --> 00:26:02,832 These results aren't even close. 524 00:26:02,832 --> 00:26:07,082 Martin Trenway could not have raped Heather Stark. 525 00:26:11,852 --> 00:26:14,777 The whole time he was raping me I was staring right in his face 526 00:26:14,777 --> 00:26:17,442 so that I could remember everything about him. 527 00:26:17,442 --> 00:26:19,417 This is wrong. 528 00:26:19,417 --> 00:26:20,627 It's gotta be wrong. 529 00:26:20,627 --> 00:26:23,298 The DNA can't be wrong, Heather. 530 00:26:23,298 --> 00:26:25,593 Ms. Stark, listen, I... 531 00:26:25,593 --> 00:26:27,927 Get the hell away from me! 532 00:26:31,577 --> 00:26:33,060 Detectives. 533 00:26:33,060 --> 00:26:34,918 Counselor. 534 00:26:37,372 --> 00:26:41,641 How, how could I be so sure about this and be wrong? 535 00:26:41,641 --> 00:26:43,729 It's gotta be a mistake, don't you think? 536 00:26:43,729 --> 00:26:46,713 Heather, I'm sorry. Another man did this to you. 537 00:26:46,713 --> 00:26:49,326 Now, we'll run the DNA through the system. 538 00:26:49,326 --> 00:26:51,073 If he's been arrested for any crime anywhere, 539 00:26:51,073 --> 00:26:52,383 we'll get him. 540 00:26:52,383 --> 00:26:54,941 It's too late now. 541 00:26:56,737 --> 00:26:58,855 I'm sorry. 542 00:27:03,656 --> 00:27:05,766 She's right. Even if we find whoever raped her, 543 00:27:05,766 --> 00:27:08,283 the statute of limitations has run out. 544 00:27:08,283 --> 00:27:10,037 She never gets justice. 545 00:27:10,037 --> 00:27:11,763 Hope we get some for Nikki West. 546 00:27:11,763 --> 00:27:12,937 We've got Trenway. 547 00:27:12,937 --> 00:27:14,384 If he's the man who attacked her. 548 00:27:14,384 --> 00:27:15,535 It is him. 549 00:27:15,535 --> 00:27:18,123 No alibi, the ID of his hand, the fingerprints on his car. 550 00:27:18,123 --> 00:27:20,225 We put him on trial now, we make him a martyr. 551 00:27:20,225 --> 00:27:22,608 He's already the poster boy for mistaken identity. 552 00:27:22,608 --> 00:27:24,573 - Well, what more do you need? - Short of a confession? 553 00:27:24,573 --> 00:27:28,324 Another victim who will testify Trenway raped her. 554 00:27:32,569 --> 00:27:35,123 We already went back five years. Didn't find anything. 555 00:27:35,123 --> 00:27:36,568 Novak wants us to go back further. 556 00:27:36,568 --> 00:27:38,576 Find someone she can put on the stand as a Molineux witness 557 00:27:38,576 --> 00:27:40,151 to swear Trenway raped her. 558 00:27:40,151 --> 00:27:41,762 You know, show that he'd done it before. 559 00:27:41,762 --> 00:27:46,438 I don't even know why there is a statute of limitations on rape anymore now that we have DNA. 560 00:27:46,438 --> 00:27:50,579 To prevent eyewitnesses like Heather Stark from accusing the wrong person. 561 00:27:52,118 --> 00:27:54,019 - What time she get here? - She never left. 562 00:27:54,019 --> 00:27:55,861 Some people shouldn't be allowed to drink coffee. 563 00:27:55,861 --> 00:27:57,134 Dani, what is this? 564 00:27:57,134 --> 00:27:59,237 Trenway. I got him. 565 00:27:59,370 --> 00:28:00,316 Yeah, how? 566 00:28:00,316 --> 00:28:06,285 There were 14 unsolved beatings and rapes upstate in Ithaca from 1970 to 1974, 567 00:28:06,285 --> 00:28:08,468 the same years Trenway went to college there. 568 00:28:08,468 --> 00:28:13,150 The cops said that the attacks stopped at exactly the time Trenway left 569 00:28:13,150 --> 00:28:15,051 for law school at Duke. 570 00:28:15,051 --> 00:28:16,119 Okay, let me guess. 571 00:28:16,119 --> 00:28:19,342 The police in North Carolina handled a similar string of rapes 572 00:28:19,342 --> 00:28:21,172 that started right about that same time. 573 00:28:21,172 --> 00:28:22,712 11 victims. 574 00:28:22,712 --> 00:28:26,010 From August of '74 to May of '77. 575 00:28:26,010 --> 00:28:28,065 All unsolved. But... 576 00:28:28,065 --> 00:28:31,316 I think we'll find more of Trenway's work closer to home. 577 00:28:31,316 --> 00:28:32,485 How do you figure? 578 00:28:32,485 --> 00:28:37,087 Well, Trenway rented that Jaguar to go see a client in Jersey, right? 579 00:28:37,087 --> 00:28:38,422 He lives in Connecticut and... 580 00:28:38,422 --> 00:28:40,896 He could've been raping women all over the tri-state area for years. 581 00:28:40,896 --> 00:28:41,853 But we'd never know, 582 00:28:41,853 --> 00:28:44,648 because nobody shares information across jurisdictions. 583 00:28:44,648 --> 00:28:49,043 Right, now, Trenway grew up in Queens, Douglaston. 584 00:28:49,043 --> 00:28:54,478 So I pulled all the unsolved cases from 1967 to 1970 when he was a teenager. 585 00:28:54,478 --> 00:28:56,158 No rapes with his M.O. 586 00:28:56,158 --> 00:28:58,845 But there were two assaults in his neighborhood. 587 00:28:58,845 --> 00:29:01,822 One, the victim was a guy, so we can discard that. 588 00:29:01,822 --> 00:29:07,054 The other was a woman assaulted in her house. 589 00:29:08,512 --> 00:29:10,579 Lorraine Delmas, 32. 590 00:29:10,579 --> 00:29:13,483 Broken nose, cheek bone, jaw bone. 591 00:29:13,483 --> 00:29:15,020 Where have I heard that before? 592 00:29:15,020 --> 00:29:16,545 Or seen it. 593 00:29:16,545 --> 00:29:20,265 These photos could be carbon copies of Nikki West. 594 00:29:20,265 --> 00:29:23,300 That woman would be in her 70s if she's still alive. 595 00:29:23,300 --> 00:29:25,135 I think she is. 596 00:29:25,135 --> 00:29:26,467 What makes you think that? 597 00:29:26,467 --> 00:29:28,322 I've seen this face. 598 00:29:29,445 --> 00:29:32,832 Home of Lorraine Delmas Douglaston, New York Thursday, September 28 599 00:29:40,286 --> 00:29:41,805 Mrs. Delmas. 600 00:29:42,167 --> 00:29:43,805 Miss Delmas. 601 00:29:43,805 --> 00:29:47,234 I'm detective Stabler. This my partner, detective Beck. 602 00:29:47,234 --> 00:29:50,055 I saw you in court two days ago. 603 00:29:50,055 --> 00:29:52,245 In the gallery. 604 00:29:52,245 --> 00:29:54,166 Please come in. 605 00:29:56,621 --> 00:30:00,219 I assume you are here to ask me about Marty. 606 00:30:00,770 --> 00:30:02,151 How long have you known him? 607 00:30:02,151 --> 00:30:04,266 Ever since he was a boy. 608 00:30:04,266 --> 00:30:06,239 His mother and I were best friends. 609 00:30:06,239 --> 00:30:09,985 You must've been shocked when he was accused of assaulting those women. 610 00:30:12,036 --> 00:30:14,441 It was nice you came to court to support him. 611 00:30:14,441 --> 00:30:16,835 I wanted to see what would happen. 612 00:30:16,835 --> 00:30:19,379 So you were pleased that the charges were dropped? 613 00:30:19,379 --> 00:30:20,329 Yes. 614 00:30:20,329 --> 00:30:23,438 How did you meet Marty's mother? 615 00:30:23,438 --> 00:30:26,205 Oh, Marie and I were little girls together. 616 00:30:26,205 --> 00:30:28,368 We grew up in the same town. 617 00:30:28,368 --> 00:30:29,948 In France. 618 00:30:29,948 --> 00:30:32,880 St. Remy de Provence. 619 00:30:32,880 --> 00:30:36,727 She met and married her husband there, James. 620 00:30:36,727 --> 00:30:39,078 And James' brother fell in love with me, 621 00:30:39,078 --> 00:30:41,487 and I moved here to be with him. 622 00:30:41,487 --> 00:30:44,491 But you never married. 623 00:30:46,280 --> 00:30:50,862 We, we broke up after... 624 00:30:50,862 --> 00:30:52,920 Marie died. 625 00:30:52,920 --> 00:30:55,481 Did you stay in touch with Marty? 626 00:30:55,740 --> 00:31:00,905 On her deathbed, she made me promise to take care of him. 627 00:31:01,796 --> 00:31:04,096 What about his father? 628 00:31:04,096 --> 00:31:08,336 After his mother died, Marty became a very difficult child. 629 00:31:08,336 --> 00:31:11,663 He couldn't communicate with his father. 630 00:31:11,663 --> 00:31:14,822 So he spent most of his time here with me. 631 00:31:14,822 --> 00:31:16,377 You were close. 632 00:31:16,377 --> 00:31:18,488 - Yes. - Miss Delmas... 633 00:31:18,488 --> 00:31:20,062 Please call me Lorraine. 634 00:31:20,062 --> 00:31:21,742 Lorraine... 635 00:31:22,465 --> 00:31:25,342 Why were you sitting so far away from Marty in court? 636 00:31:25,342 --> 00:31:28,899 Oh, we haven't spoken for nearly 40 years. 637 00:31:28,899 --> 00:31:30,801 Did something happen? 638 00:31:30,801 --> 00:31:32,945 Marty went away to college. 639 00:31:32,945 --> 00:31:34,711 We, we just lost touch. 640 00:31:34,711 --> 00:31:36,017 Do you remember, 641 00:31:36,017 --> 00:31:40,423 uh, was that before or after you were attacked in your home? 642 00:31:48,861 --> 00:31:50,449 I'd rather not talk about that. 643 00:31:50,449 --> 00:31:53,098 I understand it brings back painful memories. 644 00:31:53,098 --> 00:31:56,434 Lorraine, I read the police reports from that night. 645 00:31:56,434 --> 00:31:59,559 Whoever hurt you didn't break in. 646 00:32:00,925 --> 00:32:04,366 Did you know the man who attacked you? 647 00:32:08,218 --> 00:32:10,149 Well... 648 00:32:10,149 --> 00:32:13,074 it happened so long ago. 649 00:32:13,074 --> 00:32:18,962 You know, people in those days weren't afraid to open their doors. 650 00:32:18,962 --> 00:32:21,739 Would you take me home please now? 651 00:32:21,739 --> 00:32:24,270 Would you like something to eat before you go? 652 00:32:24,820 --> 00:32:26,683 Why is she protecting him? 653 00:32:26,683 --> 00:32:28,953 She's fulfilling the promise she made to Trenway's mother. 654 00:32:28,953 --> 00:32:30,672 No, I don't think that's it. 655 00:32:30,672 --> 00:32:33,446 She want to court to see Trenway finally get justice. 656 00:32:33,446 --> 00:32:35,919 Well, if that's what she wants, why won't she talk? 657 00:32:35,919 --> 00:32:38,232 'Cause she's ashamed. 658 00:32:39,596 --> 00:32:42,451 She's not going to talk to a man. 659 00:32:48,522 --> 00:32:51,091 May I come in? 660 00:32:52,561 --> 00:32:54,532 It's so hot in here. 661 00:32:54,532 --> 00:32:56,151 I brought some water. 662 00:32:56,151 --> 00:32:58,806 I'll get some glasses. 663 00:33:03,816 --> 00:33:06,698 I'm going to pour you some water now. 664 00:33:06,698 --> 00:33:08,745 Please have a seat. 665 00:33:13,625 --> 00:33:18,046 St. Remy de Provence isn't far from Avignon, right? 666 00:33:18,046 --> 00:33:24,731 Yes. / Because I spent my summers there with my parents when I was a child. 667 00:33:24,731 --> 00:33:27,579 Oh, so that is why you speak French. 668 00:33:27,579 --> 00:33:30,742 Yes, that's why. 669 00:33:31,058 --> 00:33:33,407 You must be tired. 670 00:33:33,407 --> 00:33:35,604 A little bit. 671 00:33:36,290 --> 00:33:39,329 You shouldn't be ashamed. 672 00:33:42,298 --> 00:33:44,603 Ashamed of what? 673 00:33:44,603 --> 00:33:46,953 Of what he did to you. 674 00:33:46,953 --> 00:33:49,031 Did he rape you? 675 00:33:49,031 --> 00:33:51,703 No, no I can't talk about it... 676 00:33:52,763 --> 00:33:55,281 It's OK, Madame. 677 00:33:56,520 --> 00:34:03,342 Four years ago, my husband, who was a policeman... 678 00:34:03,567 --> 00:34:07,838 was murdered. And... 679 00:34:10,089 --> 00:34:15,462 for a long time, I couldn't talk about it either. 680 00:34:16,995 --> 00:34:23,896 But once I did... 681 00:34:24,484 --> 00:34:28,549 I felt... much better. 682 00:34:30,074 --> 00:34:34,296 Nobody should have to live with this. 683 00:34:37,125 --> 00:34:39,143 I promised his mother. 684 00:34:39,143 --> 00:34:42,101 Yeah, and you kept that promise. 685 00:34:42,369 --> 00:34:45,024 You helped him. 686 00:34:45,384 --> 00:34:48,594 And now you have to help yourself. 687 00:34:55,091 --> 00:34:58,704 I didn't want to get him in trouble. 688 00:35:00,118 --> 00:35:03,742 I forced myself to forget. 689 00:35:04,415 --> 00:35:08,042 I pretended that nothing had happened. 690 00:35:09,803 --> 00:35:12,395 But you keep it inside of you. 691 00:35:12,395 --> 00:35:15,552 It eats you up. 692 00:35:17,870 --> 00:35:21,677 My fiance tried to help me... 693 00:35:21,677 --> 00:35:24,984 but I couldn't tell him anything. 694 00:35:25,983 --> 00:35:29,004 So finally, he left. 695 00:35:31,764 --> 00:35:38,917 After that, I knew that no man would ever want me. 696 00:35:41,693 --> 00:35:44,691 Did Marty attack you that night? 697 00:35:45,391 --> 00:35:47,426 It's okay. 698 00:35:47,426 --> 00:35:50,812 You don't have to protect him anymore. 699 00:36:01,460 --> 00:36:04,864 Yes, it was Marty. 700 00:36:14,803 --> 00:36:17,649 I didn't want to say it. 701 00:36:20,484 --> 00:36:22,805 It was Marty. 702 00:36:25,961 --> 00:36:28,941 Evidentiary Hearing Part 46 Monday, October 2 703 00:36:28,941 --> 00:36:32,953 He was very upset when he came over that night. 704 00:36:32,953 --> 00:36:36,392 He wouldn't, he wouldn't tell me why. 705 00:36:37,945 --> 00:36:39,986 He asked for a soda, 706 00:36:39,986 --> 00:36:44,054 and I went into the kitchen to get it. 707 00:36:45,372 --> 00:36:52,072 I was looking into the refrigerator when I was hit from behind. 708 00:36:52,072 --> 00:36:55,091 Knocked to the floor. 709 00:36:55,091 --> 00:36:57,357 It was Marty. 710 00:36:57,357 --> 00:36:59,780 He was hitting and hitting and hitting. 711 00:36:59,780 --> 00:37:00,875 You're lying! 712 00:37:00,875 --> 00:37:01,752 Why are you lying? 713 00:37:01,752 --> 00:37:03,486 You know it's true, Marty! 714 00:37:03,486 --> 00:37:05,485 You swore you wouldn't say anything! 715 00:37:05,485 --> 00:37:08,448 You grabbed that kitchen knife from the counter. 716 00:37:08,448 --> 00:37:12,805 You made me pull down my pants and you raped me! 717 00:37:13,717 --> 00:37:16,360 Miss Delmas, Mr. Trenway. 718 00:37:21,972 --> 00:37:26,638 Why didn't you tell the police that you had been raped? 719 00:37:29,822 --> 00:37:32,214 Because I was... 720 00:37:34,087 --> 00:37:36,393 because I was single. 721 00:37:36,393 --> 00:37:40,479 I was engaged to be married. And... 722 00:37:40,770 --> 00:37:45,002 I was so embarrassed, so ashamed. 723 00:37:47,376 --> 00:37:52,343 I didn't know what my fiance would do if he found out. 724 00:37:52,343 --> 00:37:55,203 And Marty was... 725 00:37:55,436 --> 00:37:57,769 family. 726 00:38:04,213 --> 00:38:06,766 Your honor, we submit that miss Delmas' testimony 727 00:38:06,766 --> 00:38:10,560 meets the standard of people vs. Molineux to present to the jury as proof 728 00:38:10,560 --> 00:38:14,547 that Martin Trenway has raped before. 729 00:38:16,630 --> 00:38:18,444 Miss Delmas... 730 00:38:18,444 --> 00:38:22,944 I am deeply sorry about the horror you experienced. 731 00:38:22,944 --> 00:38:24,722 I am equally sorry 732 00:38:24,722 --> 00:38:28,521 that we can never try Martin Trenway for what he did to you. 733 00:38:28,521 --> 00:38:33,290 But this is an evidentiary hearing, not a trial. 734 00:38:33,290 --> 00:38:36,672 And because it happened so long ago, 735 00:38:36,672 --> 00:38:40,867 and there is no proof to support your testimony, 736 00:38:40,867 --> 00:38:44,680 I cannot allow this testimony under Molineux 737 00:38:44,680 --> 00:38:49,001 on the grounds that it would be unfairly prejudicial against the defendant. 738 00:38:49,001 --> 00:38:51,217 Your honor... 739 00:38:51,217 --> 00:38:54,058 I buried it. 740 00:38:54,552 --> 00:38:56,797 Miss Delmas? 741 00:38:57,699 --> 00:39:03,235 I buried it just like I buried my memories. 742 00:39:05,090 --> 00:39:07,556 After Marty left that night, 743 00:39:07,556 --> 00:39:12,866 I took off all the clothes I was wearing and stuffed them in a box. 744 00:39:12,866 --> 00:39:18,976 There's a place in the basement between the beams. 745 00:39:19,266 --> 00:39:22,211 I hid the box there 746 00:39:22,654 --> 00:39:26,907 so that I would never see it again. 747 00:39:28,128 --> 00:39:32,108 And I didn't. Not for 40 years. 748 00:39:32,108 --> 00:39:36,827 Until I read in the newspapers that Marty... 749 00:39:36,827 --> 00:39:41,224 had raped a girl. 750 00:39:42,634 --> 00:39:45,796 I knew it had to be true. 751 00:39:46,015 --> 00:39:49,640 The DNA on Lorraine's clothes is a match. 752 00:39:49,640 --> 00:39:53,779 Martin Trenway raped Nikki West. 753 00:39:55,450 --> 00:39:58,561 I blamed myself. 754 00:39:58,780 --> 00:40:01,193 Marty was only 15. 755 00:40:01,193 --> 00:40:05,535 He had his whole life ahead of him. 756 00:40:09,040 --> 00:40:15,216 So I made myself forget what he had done. 757 00:40:19,098 --> 00:40:22,903 Maybe if I had spoken up, 758 00:40:22,903 --> 00:40:25,801 he could've been helped. 759 00:40:25,801 --> 00:40:32,790 And maybe he would not have harmed this young lady. 760 00:40:37,945 --> 00:40:41,248 I am so sorry. 761 00:40:52,987 --> 00:40:54,935 Trenway pleads guilty to raping Nikki. 762 00:40:54,935 --> 00:40:56,848 He names all the other victims he can remember, 763 00:40:56,848 --> 00:40:59,735 and in return, I recommend the maximum sentence. 764 00:40:59,735 --> 00:41:01,974 Not long enough. Trenway agreed to it? 765 00:41:01,974 --> 00:41:04,236 He's waving the white flag. He knows it's all over. 766 00:41:04,236 --> 00:41:05,546 What does all that mean? 767 00:41:05,546 --> 00:41:07,508 It means when and if he gets out of prison, 768 00:41:07,508 --> 00:41:10,788 he'll be too old to rape anybody. 769 00:41:11,009 --> 00:41:15,450 Miss Delmas, how can I ever repay you? 770 00:41:15,450 --> 00:41:17,112 Move on. 771 00:41:17,112 --> 00:41:19,768 Live your life. 772 00:41:20,199 --> 00:41:23,435 Don't lock yourself away the way I did. 773 00:41:31,009 --> 00:41:32,710 Merci. 774 00:41:34,837 --> 00:41:36,812 Merci. 775 00:41:44,519 --> 00:41:49,123 �ڸ����� - NSC �ڸ��� (http://club.nate.com/tsm) 9999 00:00:0,500 --> 00:00:2,00 www.tvsubtitles.net